Without a doubt, cheese is one of the most loved foods around the world. And it comes in a myriad of forms, from the underrated Cheddar to the luxurious Brie. Despite its popularity, many consumers are often surprised by the high price tag attached to their favourite cheese. Understanding why cheese is expensive involves delving into the challenges of sourcing, production, maturation and distribution.
SEE ALSO: List of the world’s most expensive cheeses (and why they cost so much!) →
1. The cost of quality milk
The foundation of cheese is milk, and a large quantity of milk is needed to produce a relatively small amount of cheese. On average, it takes about 4.5 litres (10 pounds) of milk to make just 0.45 kg (1 pound) of cheese. Of course, cheese made from high-quality milk will naturally be more expensive. Examples of high quality (and more expensive) milk include milk from grass-fed or organic cows, goats or sheep.
Milk production costs are influenced by numerous factors. Those include the diet and health of the animals, the farming methods used, and the cost of veterinary care. When farmers invest in sustainable practices, hormone-free feed, and humane treatment, these additional costs are reflected in the price of the milk. And, subsequently, in the price of the cheese.
2. The cheesemaking process
Next, the process of turning milk into cheese is complex and labour-intensive. This involves several stages including curdling, cutting, heating, draining, moulding and pressing. Each step requires careful monitoring and precise control to ensure the right texture and flavour of the final product. Small-scale or artisanal producers often rely on traditional, manual methods rather than automated processes, further increasing labour costs.
Moreover, the use of specific starter cultures and enzymes is crucial for developing the flavour and texture of cheese. Many other ingredients, such as rennet, can be expensive, especially if they are sourced naturally rather than synthesized. The use of high-quality or specialty cultures adds to the production cost, which is then passed on to the consumer.
3. Ageing and maturation of cheese
One of the defining characteristics of many cheeses is their ageing process, which can range from a few weeks to several years. Ageing not only enhances the flavour and texture of cheese but also significantly impacts its cost. During ageing, cheese is stored in controlled environments where temperature and humidity are carefully regulated. This process requires dedicated space, equipment and ongoing maintenance, which all contribute to the overall expense.
Additionally, aged cheeses often lose moisture over time. As a result, they weigh less at the end of the ageing process than they did initially. This reduction in weight, combined with the costs of long-term storage, makes aged cheeses more expensive to produce. The longer the ageing process, the more these costs accumulate, leading to higher prices for aged cheeses like Parmigiano Reggiano or aged Gouda.
4. Specialty and artisanal cheeses
While mass-produced cheeses may be more affordable due to economies of scale, artisanal cheeses are often handcrafted in small batches with a focus on quality and traditional techniques. These cheeses are typically made from milk sourced from a single herd or farm. And the production often involves a high degree of manual labour and skill.
The uniqueness of these cheeses, whether in flavour, texture or method of production, often commands a premium price. Artisanal producers also face higher costs for raw materials and labour, as well as challenges in distribution and marketing. Unlike large-scale manufacturers, they do not benefit from bulk purchasing of ingredients or streamlined production processes. Hence, their cheeses are often more expensive.
5. Geographical indications and import costs
Some of the world’s most renowned cheeses are protected by geographical indications such as the AOP and PDO. Those stamps legally restrict their production to specific regions using traditional methods. For example, Parmigiano Reggiano can only be made in certain provinces of Italy under strict regulations. These protections ensure quality and authenticity but also mean that these cheeses cannot be mass-produced or replicated elsewhere. Thus, those protection authorities maintain their scarcity and high value.
For consumers outside these regions, import costs further drive up the price. Importing cheese involves tariffs, shipping fees and customs duties, all of which can add significantly to the retail price. Furthermore, imported cheeses must also be transported and stored under specific conditions to maintain their quality, adding another layer of cost.
6. Expensive supply chain and distribution
The logistics of getting cheese from the producer to the consumer can be surprisingly complicated. Cheese is a perishable product that requires careful handling, temperature control and timely distribution. From the point of production to the retail shelf, cheese must be kept at specific temperatures and humidity to prevent spoilage and maintain its quality.
This need for a cold chain—a temperature-controlled supply chain—adds to transportation and storage costs. For smaller producers, especially those distributing across international borders, these logistics can be a significant expense. Additionally, specialty retailers who stock artisanal or imported cheeses must account for the costs of maintaining proper storage conditions.
7. Market dynamics and consumer demand
The price of cheese is also influenced by market dynamics such as supply and demand. Consumer preferences for high-quality, artisanal and organic products have grown in recent years, pushing up demand for these premium cheeses. As demand increases, so do prices, especially if the supply is limited due to factors like seasonal production or the limited availability of specific types of milk.
In contrast, mass-produced cheeses benefit from stable, year-round supply and economies of scale, making them more affordable. However, even these products can see price fluctuations due to changes in the cost of milk, fuel, and other inputs.
8. Other economic factors and inflation
Like all products, the cost of cheese is subject to broader economic factors such as inflation, changes in the cost of feed and fuel, and fluctuations in currency exchange rates. When the cost of raw materials like grain (for feed) or petrol (for transportation) rises, these increases are often passed down the supply chain to the consumer.
Besides, economic instability in key cheese-producing regions can also affect global prices.
Conclusion
The high cost of cheese is the result of a confluence of factors, from the raw material costs of high-quality milk to the complex and labour-intensive production process, ageing requirements and logistical challenges.
While cheese may seem expensive, understanding the intricate journey from farm to table reveals why this beloved food commands a premium price. Each slice of artisanal cheese carries with it a story of craftsmanship, tradition, and a deep-rooted cultural heritage that makes it worth every penny.
Jonah is a a hipster, eco-warrior and slow food afficionado. Coming from a scientific background, Jonah has a particular interest in cheese science. And yes, he loves a good cheese pun!
